The Great Game of Geopolitical Chess-Board
The Game of chess requires two opponents, the pawns are many but the objective is to capture the opponent’s king and to keep it in check . But, in the game of geopolitics,there can be one power centre i.e.unipolarity or hegemon , two power centres
i.e. bipolarity or more than two power centres
i.e. multipolarity.
In this article , We’ll be analyzing the evolution of world order , some of its theoretical paradigms and its tenets. We are going to ascertain the global
game play and the route to international stability .
ERA OF BIPOLARITY
Balance of power is perceived by the realists as the sole pathway to ensure peace and stability , and is the consequence of structural dynamics of the international system. In simple words -‘ THE OBVIOUS CONSEQUENCE ’
The end of second world war is a landmark in contemporary world politics , it was the beginning of the cold war. Some believe that dropping of nuclear bombs in Japan was less to do with the surrender of Japan and more intended to stop the USSR from making military and political gains in Asia and elsewhere . It was to show Moscow that
US is supreme. As ‘Hans Morgenthau’,said
-Power is the immediate goal and the egoism & anarchy results in power politics.Hence, whatever the motives the consequence was ‘BIPOLARITY’.
NAM as a movement of third world countries
emerged to keep former colonies and infant nations to stay away from power rivalry. It was also seen as a means of taking concessions from both the blocs.With the collapse of Berlin wall in 1989 and the subsequent chain of events resulted in
the collapse of Warsaw pact - the end of cold war as the end of bipolarity .
THE US HEGEMONY AND THE
UNIPOLAR WORLD ORDER
The disintegration of USSR was the collapse of communism. The rivalry of capitalism &
communism also started settling.
As said by some scholars , like Francis Fukuyama , in his paper -’The end of history’- It is the victory of capitalist & liberal model . The shock therapy started serving the purpose of first world .It started shaping world around the western economic model , dollarization of global economy. Traditional Imperialism has given way to ‘new-colonialism’ which has been seen as ‘economic imperialism’ or
more specifically ‘dollar imperialism’ and the
hegemony of the US was the ‘ new normal’.
CONTEMPORARY GEOPOLITICS
As the world order is determined by the changing fate of great powers . The concept of polarity never lost its relevance,as neo-realists believe that there is general bias in the international system in
favor of balance.The economical progress of the China comes into picture . China accounted for 19% of global economy in PPP terms . It started influencing the world by going against the very tenets of marxism, through its debt-trap diplomacy. It’s well known ‘belt & road initiative ‘started contesting the hegemony of global connectivity by maritime United States (US). Then the IMEC came as a counter move. The US wants to retain its sole
rights to weaponize interdependence to prevent China from dominating . US started perceiving the rise of China,an another communist regime , as the challenge to its hegemony . It is evident from the shifting priorities of US . The rising importance of groupings like QUAD & AUKUS and the
strengthening of alliances with other regional powers of Indian ocean region. IS THE END MULTIPOLARITY ?
As Liberals, believe that there is moral dimension to human nature , most commonly reflected in the doctrine of human rights . This moral dimension is grounded in a strong faith in reason and progress . Reason dictates that everyone should treat each other with respect and dignity . The idealistic principles of Kant started taking its place among these dynamics. When thinkers like , Hobbes , Locke highlighted , the fact that only a sovereign power can safeguard state from chaos . Liberal believed same to be true for international politics as well . This provided the basis for the
establishment of liberal institutionalism .
As ,Woodrow Wilson put , “it would turn ‘jungle’ of
international politics into ‘zoo’ ”.
Gone were the times when the power equations and hobbesian tendencies were perceived as the only factors in shaping global dynamics ,When the world for some was about power maximization and for others it was about relative gains . Both the lenses are becoming outdated now .
The approaches has changed and the world accordingly .When we see it with the lens of Carlos
Escude , a peripheral realist , believes that the hierarchies are like - Rule makers , rebels and Rule
takers . The world is heading towards multipolarity. The definition of security has changed. The
factors , other than state and non-state actors , started emerging as the global threats like - climate change , refugee crisis , interconnected economies etc. Countries are cooperating on such issues globally and the equations keeps changing. The traditional role of P-5 being the only rule maker, is getting challenged by other players , as global south and India ( representing itself as the leader of Global south ) are playing an important role on shaping world’s important decisions .
The Euro-centric approach has been exposed and the issues of global south started getting its right
place on the tables of decision making . The Global south started becoming aware and more
ambitious towards their own national interests . The world is experiencing a watershed phase , by a
geopolitical & economic powershift from west to Afro-Asian powers .
But as neo-realist believe , such cooperation is always prone to break down , because of the
emphasis on relative gains. As it can be seen in the current Russia-Ukraine war , the failure of
liberal institutions like United Nations .The institutions like UN , WTO , WHO are losing their
relevance .
But at the same time , the regional institutions like BRICS , SAARC , ASEAN , QUAD , G20 are
becoming more and more important . The times were gone when the global politics was about only
major players , the regional issues are more relevant now . Even the De-dollarisation of economies is also the hot topic with systems like rupee-rouble arrangement are getting explored. These issues are resulting in the rise of regional powers & are characterized by a return to a multipolar world order .
MULTIPOLARITY & STABILITY
History of multipolarity has not been kind to stability. Two world wars were its manifestation. So
how can all players ensure that the multipolarity becomes a vehicle for sustainable development
and peace ?
A multipolar world order can contribute to international stability by fostering a more balanced
distribution of power among major global actors. In such a system , Multiple power centers are less
likely to engage in direct military conflicts because the costs and risks are higher. Each major player
understands that aggression could lead to counterbalancing coalitions, promoting peaceful
resolutions to disputes.
A multipolar system encourages states to monitor and balance each other's actions. This can
prevent any single country from becoming too dominant and acting unilaterally, thus reducing the
potential for global conflicts.
Different poles bring diverse perspectives and interests to the table, which can lead to more
comprehensive and balanced international decision-making. This diversity can also help address global challenges effectively.
In a multipolar world, countries are more likely to engage in economic cooperation and integration,
as they recognize the mutual benefits. Economic interdependence can be a powerful deterrent to
conflict.
States may invest more in soft power and diplomacy as they compete for influence in a multipolar system. This can lead to increased international cooperation and a focus on non-military solutions to conflicts. However, it's important to note that a multipolar world also comes with challenges, such as the potential for proxy conflicts and coordination difficulties among major powers.
Therefore, effective international institutions and mechanisms for conflict resolution remain
essential for maintaining stability in such a system.
Also does an interconnected and independent world require that we abandon academic disciplines and self - contained theories ? Do we have to learn to think across paradigms or perhaps beyond paradigms ( Sil & Katzenstein ) ? We can also think in terms of social constructivism , as Alexander Wendt asserted that ‘anarchy is what states make of it’. Paradigm may also become prison and limits our thoughts. The world is dynamic and it is unhelpful to merely select a theoretical box within which to think. It is highly unlikely that a single paradigm - be it realism , liberalism ,constructivism , feminism or whatever - constitute the final word on any particular issue .
The most powerful will have to give up the inclinations to view themselves as exceptional in favor of universal humanistic , an become capable of celebrating global growth . The Globalisation has connected the world and the growth is now connected as well . Enlightened political leadership, the concept of global citizenship expect stability & cooperation and MULTIPOLARITY IS THE
ANSWER.
Very well articulated 👍
ReplyDeleteVery well written you have put it down well
ReplyDelete